Comments on: To My Jewish Friends/Readers, Happy Purim; To My Christian Friends/Reader, Happy Easter

By: Shy Guy

Shy Guy — Sun, 23 Mar 2008 03:39:13 +0000

Thank you and I look forward to when you celebrate both Easter and Purim. G-d bless you.
Posted by: Blayne at March 21, 2008 12:45 PM
===============================================
Puke. Heaven forbid.
To paraphrase Henny Youngman: “Take our dead Jew – PLEASE!!!!”
“שהם משתחווים להבל וריק ומתפללים לאל לא יושיע”
Debbie, this is what happens when you try to be nice. They want to reciprocate by sucking the Neshama out of us. Especially true of Easter. It’s all about the Joooooooooz, you know. One thing to live and let live. Another thing to encourage them.
It is still Purim this year here in Jerusalem. Must deliver Mishloach Manot and the Chardonnay is cooling for the Seudah this afternoon. I wonder which of my kids will help drag me back home. My wife won’t come near me.

By: Ben-Yehudah

Ben-Yehudah — Sat, 22 Mar 2008 14:40:20 +0000

B”H I have heard (unconfirmed) the Hebrew on this tomb is the only Hebrew allowed to be publicly displayed in Iran. Wonder what they’re afraid of?
Purim, it is important to note, is a very politically-incorrect holiday. Or at least it is based on a very politically incorrect book in the Bible. Leftist, former member of Kenesset Yossi Sarid YSh”W even suggested at one time that the public reading of the Book of Esther (one of the four main observances of the holiday, along with a festive meal, giving gifts of food to friends, and giving charity to the needy) should be banned.
Book-banning in Israel is imminent.

By: LibertarianBulbasaur

LibertarianBulbasaur — Fri, 21 Mar 2008 23:46:34 +0000

Mark,
Can’t speak for Debbie on this one, but for me the deal-killer is this:
For Jews, the coming of the Messiah by definition brings world peace and perfection of humanity, all that good stuff.
This is not currently the state of the world.
Therefore, the Messiah has not come yet.
As for the link you provided, including prophecies such as:
The Messiah would be born of a virgin.
The Messiah would be God.
The Messiah would be both man and God.
The Messiah would be resurrected by God.
And so on…
Even ignoring the fact that Jews would consider some major stuff in here to be mistranslations of the Hebrew (The Hebrew word that was translated as “virgin” is “almah” which just means Young Woman), in order to believe that Jesus fits all of these criteria, you have to already believe that the New Testament is factually correct. I do not. As a whole, Jews do not. Unless you can convince me as a skeptic that the New Testament is a divine document, I’m operating under the assumption that it isn’t.
But anyway, like I said, there’s still no peace on earth, humans are not perfect yet, so the whole argument is a non-starter.
The following website has more details about this topic, with many more reasons than what I gave here:
http://www.aish.com/spirituality/philosophy/Why_Dont_Jews_Believe_In_Jesus$.asp

By: billybob

billybob — Fri, 21 Mar 2008 21:03:51 +0000

@Uncle Tim:
As we are now into the “Holy” hours of Jewish tradition you will have to wait till Sunday or Monday if Debbie sees or chooses to respond to your questions.

By: mplumb

mplumb — Fri, 21 Mar 2008 19:28:45 +0000

That pastry looks wonderful. The ear reference is a little less than appetizing, though.

By: AppleCider123

AppleCider123 — Fri, 21 Mar 2008 18:02:56 +0000

Despite the fact the my great-grand father was one of the most famous young talmid-hakkams of the Ukraine and one of the leading experts for the defense in case of M. Beilis (I am not a Jew, I have only one Jewish grandfather who in 1920th converted to Christianity, but I am a friend and very loyal) this marvelous story still makes my heart heavy. I always think – how old were the sons of Haman? How many of them were still children? May be one was still breast-fed? Again – I am the loyalest friend possible, always standing with prosecuted Jews and Israel, but this story makes me really grieving. I am very sorry for this comment out of harmony, but it’ll be worse if I’ll not say about it.

By: Uncle Tim

Uncle Tim — Fri, 21 Mar 2008 17:03:04 +0000

Hi Deb, Happy Pruim to you! You may or may not remember me. No matter though, cuz I have a question for you. You seem like a very intelligent, reasonable Jewess and person so I am curious as to your continued faith, Judaism. It is obvious from your posts that your are at least conversationally familiar with Christianity and its tenets as well. So my question is: with all of the Torah prophecy pointing to Jesus a Messiah and Christ, why do you not accept this and profess faith in Him? I wonder if you are like many Jews who have never been truly exposed to the vast amount of Torah prophecy relating to Jesus birth, life, death and resurrection or if you are one who simply denies the validity of said prophecy? I am not asking to attack your faith at all, but because I believe in Jesus as Christ and Messiah. I believe that the question of whether He is or is not should be the central question in the life of every human being, Jews included and I just wonder whether you have ever really done the leg work and research to examine this for yourself. I apologize if this is annoying or something you have been asked a thousand times before, but I am genuinely curious.
Just around 50 of the prophecies (out of nearly 500) I refer to are listed on the link provided below. If you have time I would like to hear you answer.
http://biblia.com/jesusbible/isaiah2.htm
Thanks!
Mark

By: Infidel Pride

Infidel Pride — Fri, 21 Mar 2008 16:42:45 +0000

Debbie
A happy Purim to you and all Jewish friends, and a happy Easter to all Christian friends. In addition to that, a happy (belated) Holi to all Hindus reading this – I guess with Nowroz, that makes it 4 religions celebrating today (yesterday for the Hindus). I don’t know if the Buddhists have anything running today, but I heard somewhere that most of the world’s religions (not including Islam) have something going on today – a rarity.
Mr Ghost
Nowroz is celebrated by as a part of Persian culture, being as it is Zoroastrian based. The countries where it is celebrated were a part of the pre-Islamic Persian empire, but that doesn’t make it Islamic in and of itself: you don’t see it being celebrated in Pakistan, Saudi Arabia, Egypt or even among the Shia in Lebanon. OTOH, it is celebrated by Zoroastrians in India.

By: Anonymous1

Anonymous1 — Fri, 21 Mar 2008 13:59:30 +0000

Happy Purim, Debbie. I went to the glatt kosher grocery to buy hamantashen but all they had were the diabetic ones, so I went to the regular grocery store. They had a hamantashen display, and I got a few, although the chocolate chip ones are a bit goyishe. I was surprised they were almost $1.50 each. That seems like a lot.

By: Mister Ghost

Mister Ghost — Fri, 21 Mar 2008 13:58:40 +0000

Happy Purim, Debbie. In Iran, Iraq, Kurdistan, and countries in Central Asia like Uzbekistan, they are celebrating Newroz today, the first day of Spring. It’s no coincidence that all these celebrations occur in the same time frame, they are part and parcel of the influence of Zoroastrianism, the first monotheistic religion, on Chrisitianity and Judaism, and even Islam (Newroz is celebrated mainly in Islamic countries).
Zoroastrianism was the first to bequeath upon us: “The belief in a saviour – the dualism of good and evil, light and darkness – the belief in angels and archangels – Satan as the epitome of evil and the adversary of God – the doctrine of an afterlife and the immortality of the soul – the last judgement – reward and punishment by divine justice – the notion of Hell, Purgatory and Paradise – the resurrection of the dead – apocalyptic beliefs – millenial periods – destruction of the wicked and renovation of the world at the end of time.”