February 21, 2007, - 1:22 pm

Fish Identity Theft

This one is not a political issue. It’s a consumer issue.
If you’re like me and love to eat fish (Salmon is my favorite–especially the rare Copper River Salmon, only available two weeks out of the year), you’ll be disturbed to find out that several restaurants in Florida are engaging in “fish fraud.”
Undercover agents for the Florida Attorney General’s office found that a number of restaurants were subsituting undesirable species of fish for Grouper and Red Snapper in what they served to restaurant patrons. 17 of 24 restaurants in the Madeira Beach area did not serve what they claimed was Grouper.
According to The Washington Post, DNA analysis showed that what patrons were told was grouper was actually Asian Catfish, Emperor, Painted Sweetlips (huh?), and even types of fish that could not be identified. Yuck!

Asian Catfish is Posing as Grouper

And the problem is nationwide:

“This problem is rampant across America,” said Mark Kinsey, a special agent for the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration who enforces marine resource laws. “And it isn’t just grouper.”
Much of the reason for the questionable grouper, red snapper and other fish stems from a simple matter of supply and demand, regulators and industry officials say.
With the popularity of grouper rising nationwide and the domestic catch at times limited by federal guidelines, restaurateurs have relied on imports to fill the gap.
The quality of those imports has proved harder to control, even as the lower prices — often a small fraction of domestic prices — have made the imports irresistible.
In many instances, not only is the “grouper” in fact farm-raised Asian catfish from Vietnam or other species that swim with grouper, but the filets have shown signs of salmonella and traces of illegal carcinogenic fungicides, NOAA law enforcement officials said.
In December, a Panama City businessman pleaded guilty to marketing more than a million pounds of Asian catfish as grouper, a remarkable volume considering that the domestic annual catch is about 10 million pounds. Yet law enforcement officers said they think larger cases are out there. . . .
In August, the St. Petersburg Times reported that at six of 11 area restaurants sampled, the “grouper” was actually something else, according to DNA tests. One restaurant was charging $23 for “champagne braised black grouper” but was instead serving tilapia.
A television station in Fort Myers and the Daytona Beach News-Journal followed with similar findings.
“People who don’t know us are asking, ‘Is that really grouper?’ ” said Stephanie Berry, a manager at Dockside Dave’s St. Pete Beach, which many locals say serves the best grouper sandwich.
The texture and taste of real grouper are much different from those of the Asian catfish, which is its most common substitute. Grouper costs more because it tastes better. Moreover, Asian catfish filets are often thin and small; those of grouper, a much larger fish, are larger and thicker.

In my case, it’s even more of a concern because while Grouper is kosher, Catfish is not. (Fish are kosher if, when they were alive, they had both fins and scales–which is why shellfish and swordfish, for example are not kosher.) This rip-off can happen even at a kosher restaurant, where they don’t always know what their fishmonger is selling them.
More evidence that you don’t always get what you ordered.
**** UPDATE: A federal agent writes that fish identity fraud is even worse than diagnosed in the Washington Post piece referenced above:

I was a successful restaurant manager before ruining my life by joining INS. Fishswapping was an everyday reality in the business. BTW-there is no such thing as Chilean Sea bass. It is actually Patagonian Toothfish, but that doesn’t sound as appetizing, does it? This is not news to me though. I never eat fish at restaurants.

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

8 Responses

I eat a lot of fish, and I like Salmon much the same as you. I also like Sea Bass and eat plenty of it when it’s on sale. I am often skeptical even at my local fish market when buying “Chilean Sea Bass”. I mean, was the fish caught specifically in Chile?! I often doubt it, since Sea Bass are plentiful from Cabo San Lucas to Santa Barbara. Same thing when I buy Salmon; Is it actually Coho, or Sockeye, or even Atlantic Salmon when they claim it is?!

Yiddish Steel on February 21, 2007 at 1:50 pm

I’m one of those “nothing from the sea” kinds of eaters, so this doesn’t worry me. I take Omega-3 pills every day and I’m good. I do, however, wonder if the meat I’m getting in restaurants is always what they claim it is. I think I’m better off not knowing.

Stealthkix on February 21, 2007 at 3:50 pm

Stealthkix said;
“I do, however, wonder if the meat I’m getting in restaurants is always what they claim it is. I think I’m better off not knowing.”
Why are there no stray cats or dogs in Chinatown?

Thee_Bruno on February 21, 2007 at 4:04 pm

i think we need to call the cods, it was a fluke i got sucker punch by the bass player ,he was covered with muscles

PNAMARBLE on February 21, 2007 at 8:37 pm

Long time deep sea fisherman. One of my old mates owned one of the better restaurants in the South Bay and he specialized in many kinds of fish. He told me he served bonita at least a third of the time—bonita is a plentiful fish off SoCal—and he could disguise the taste by soaking it in beer or milk for 12 hours and then flavor it with all kinds of things that great cooks know. Unless you are a true fish eater who can actually tell the differences you will be fooled. He had a Duncan Hines five star rating and another top rating from another of those restaurant raters. I doubt that much has changed because sometimes you just can’t buy the fish that people want to order.

Duke on February 21, 2007 at 8:45 pm

Is shrimp Kosher?
I get all my fish meals at Long John Silvers. It was grandmas favorite, and mine also. Am I low class?

Dr.Dale on February 21, 2007 at 10:09 pm

Red Lobster is to seafood what Olive Garden is to Italian food. By the same token, LJS is to seafood what McDonalds is to steak. However, as far as class goes, to judge a person by what they choose to eat is not very classy. So eat what you like and don’t worry about what some rich guy’s wife thinks.

Stealthkix on February 22, 2007 at 10:46 am

Published data are inadequate to determine whether chronic use of amphetamines may cause similar suppression of growth, however, it is anticipated that they likely have this effect as well. ,

bxzcmvn- on June 3, 2011 at 7:52 pm

Leave a Reply

* denotes required field