March 8, 2010, - 11:13 am

Harassed by the U.S. Census: A Friend Tells Her Frightening Story; Plus Important Video

By Debbie Schlussel

A good friend of mine had the misfortune of experiencing an important–and scary–preview of what might face you, this year, as Census workers try to pry information from you beyond what is required by the U.S. Constitution.

Last summer, my friend was selected for the “pilot program” for the U.S. Census and tells me the frightening story of how U.S. Census workers repeatedly harassed her because she refused to fill out the ten-page questionnaire (which asked detailed, intrusive questions about her insurance, her kids’ schooling, how it was paid for and how they were transported there, etc.).  Because she refused to fill out the form,  a census worker visited her home over ten times, trying to threaten her into filling out the form.  The census worker even put a copy of “the law” in her mailbox, with something about being prosecuted highlighted.  The census worker told my friend that her participation was necessary to determine government social services, to which my friend replied that she doesn’t depend on the government and that they should pry into the lives of those who take welfare checks.

census2010

My friend, a teacher, wondered how a tiny requirement in the U.S. Constitution, requiring a count of American residents, resulted in Big Brother government suddenly demanding detailed personal information about her family.  My friend repeatedly told the census worker, “We have four people in our household.    That’s all I’m required to tell you, and that’s all you need to know.”  Unfortunately, shortly after that, my friend and her husband were audited by the IRS over an alleged discrepancy of $150.  Here’s more from my friend:

I was sent the census “pilot” form, this summer,  It was very long and intrusive.  It asked personal questions about where and how my kids got to school.  When I refused to fill it out, I was relentlessly harassed by a census worker.  Her name was Carol Emory and she threatened me with prosecution after she attempted to tell me what the Constitution said.  I told her that I was a U.S. History teacher and knew exactly what it said. I also told her that I was a member of the NRA and not to come back to my house!

More people need to know that their rights are being violated.

In case you don’t know, here’s all the U.S. Constitution says about the Census, in Article I, Section 2:

The actual Enumeration shall be made within three Years after the first Meeting of the Congress of the United States, and within every subsequent Term of ten Years, in such Manner as they shall by Law direct.

That’s it. That’s all it says, and that’s in a section about how Representatives to Congress are apportioned. There is nothing there about how many toilets you have or how your kids get to school. It’s no-one’s business . . . especially not the government’s.

Related Posts with Thumbnails
Print Friendly



Tags: , , , , , , , , ,

81 Responses

i have 3 different census workers at my door asking about a neighbor. (i live in an apartment) i have told each and every one of them that i DO NOT know the people. one of the workers wrote that down but yet they still keep knocking on my door trying to get info for someone i don’t even know.

Kim on June 7, 2010 at 4:36 pm

How funny…I filled out my Census form and sent it back over a month ago…now they keep calling my husband, who is on a military deployment…only they won’t let him answer any of the questions regarding his own home, or family…they insist on telling him that the only person who can answer these questions is me….but they don’t call me…they keep calling him…over and over and over again.

Just had a friend of mine from high school tell me that the Census worker casing her neighborhood is on the Sexual Predator list…now that’s scary.

Asil on June 7, 2010 at 8:42 pm

I have had them endlessly harass me on the phone after I filled the form out 2xs and talked to someone they sent to my door…. anyway, i thought i would turn it into something funny. Please read…
http://itsgrindingmygears.blogspot.com/2010/06/dear-mr-census-worker.html

holly on June 17, 2010 at 10:01 pm

Same issue as Kim…I just moved to my place about a month ago. FINALLY met that neighbor about 3 days ago, and she said, “Well, I’m not calling…sorry they keep bothering you but I don’t feel like it.” What a bitch.

Needless to say, I put a sign on my door saying that if they knock, I will call the police.

Cassie on June 25, 2010 at 3:54 pm

I sent my form in during the week that I got it, but apparently, this entitles these Census workers to bother me ANYWAY, about neighbors who I don’t know and care even less about. This fruit loop rings our doorbell at 8 in the morning, and then again ON THE SAME DAY at 11 AM. I finally answer the door, find out who it is, and tell him that if he wants my neighbor, he should go bother my neighbor. I make it clear that I don’t want this to happen again. Guess who just rang our bell this morning…BEFORE going to the neighbor’s house? Then he went to the neighbor’s house, and the guy threatened to find his baseball bat. What is with these people?

Nick on July 31, 2010 at 3:26 pm

You are an idiot. Stop using so much lipliner and peroxide and you might be able to read your own writing, where you quoted the Constitution above. Read where you quoted, “in such Manner as they shall by Law direct.” That’s right there in your Constitution, and, the Congress decides, as allowed by that phrase, what will be asked each ten years. And, while there are some census workers who obviously went overboard with threats of physical violence, which were unauthorized by the census and fireable offenses, there were many respondents–people like you–who went overboard breaking the law by refusing to comply with the census questions which were DECIDED BY CONGRESS and therefore part of your legal responsibility under the Constitution. Congress has people from both parties, and, there was no big public fight over what questions to ask, because a bi-partisan governmental body, your Congress, agreed on those questions! Including many Republicans!

That leaves the IMPACT of you and yours, aka “census refusers,” on your communities and taxpayers. Every time we had to come to your door, it cost taxpayers $46. Guess you should’ve answered the first time, huh. And for every person who was not properly enumerated, your community lost $1,300/year for ten years. So a family of four refusers cost their community $52,000 for roads, hospitals, schools, busses, police, etc. for the next decade. Good job, idiot.

Lastly, you whiners who claim you sent your form in. Maybe you did! But, this is the government we’re talking about. What part of, “it got lost” surprises you? The ONLY way to rectify that NOW is to cooperate with the door-to-door census taker. And by the way, guess what the number #1 tactic of people who secretly REFUSE to participate in the Census is? Tell the worker at the door you mailed it in, and slam said door.

By the way, being a history “teacher,” you should have known what that last phrase of the law meant. I guess it’s true what they say–those who can, do. Those who can’t, well, they teach. Congratulations.

Census worker with a brain on August 3, 2010 at 9:38 am

    Hey census worker with a brain … re-read Article I, Section 2 one more time, and think back to your English class. The subject of the sentence is “Enumeration.” The phrase “…in such Manner as they shall by Law direct.” is the process by which the Enumeration will be conducted, as directed by law. How are the Census bureaucrats indoctrinating someone so brainy? And don’t lecture anyone about the cost. It is far less costly to simply ask for the number in each household. And while you are at it, stop calling people names and labeling them; stick to the facts and provide logical arguments.

    Gordon on August 5, 2010 at 12:18 pm

      Even though I filled in the form completely, they keep calling me to clarify my information. They ask repetitive questions that go on forever basically restating what I put on my form. What a waste of our taxpayer money!!! The misuse must stop!!!!

      Fed Up on August 5, 2010 at 2:42 pm

    HUH? You ramble and bounce around so much it’s more like ‘brainless’! I felt like I was watching a tennis game when I read your reply…

    sgt on December 13, 2010 at 3:30 pm

Well said, history teacher. “Enumeration” is all that is Constitutionally authorized. We sent our form in four months ago, and have a proof of mailing receipt, answered the 10 questions in accordance with the law….and guess what… late July and we have three different census trolls visiting as late as 8 pm, going right through gates, no tresspassing signs, no census bag or badge, won’t leave a card. Well, I’d love some advice from anyone who cares to share it. According to 18 section 241 of the U.S.C., they are totally violating the law and could be fined and go to jail. Also census website claims July 10 was the final day for the stalkers, oops workers to cease, and allow us the other Constitutional right, the right to be left alone, on our own lands.

Tia on August 5, 2010 at 5:01 pm

I just chewed a census worker out today and told him that if he comes back that I will call the police. I called his supervisor and his supervisor’s supervisor. I told them they are harassing me. I filled out the census form with the number of people in my household and sent it in. They then had a worker come to my door and my wife filled in the rest of the information with her against my wishes. They then send this 3rd guy out again and my wife refused to answer his questions. He then told her that he would have to come back 8 more times. Next time they come back, I’m going to record it and put it on Youtube. Gonna title it, “Census Worker Harrasing Me.”

Steve on August 13, 2010 at 12:10 pm

I filled out the mail-in form accurately and mailed it in. Then a census worker came by a few weeks later and we sat down and filled out the form. No problem.

Then a census worker came to my door a month later and started asking me about me, my neighbors, who owned the property, etc. I told her I’m the only person at this unit, to go away, and that I had already done my part.

I thought I was finished with these idiots, but guess what? A census worker came back a few weeks later and started asking me about my landlord, the other units on the property, how many people, blah blah blah. Again, I told her I lived here and that was it. I actually had to point out my unit number which is right on the door. Again, “This is my unit number, I am the only person living here”. DUH!

I didn’t get upset with these creeps until today when there were TWO of them at the door. I was on the phone and asked them if they could come back later. They didn’t say “Sorry, excuse us, we’ll come back in 30 minutes”. Instead, the woman started interrupting me, asking the same things about the other units on the property, who was living there, etc. Very, very rude.

I think the Census Bureau is yet another example of our inefficient bureaucracy. Anyone with a computer and access to Google Maps can take a look at the satellite images and property lines to figure out what’s going on. I seem to be able to find out just about anything about anyone before I go to their door, so why are these census workers stumbling around like a bunch of idiots, and why are they so rude?

Seems like a real waste to me. Maybe they need better training.

Project None on August 13, 2010 at 8:01 pm

For four days now, I have had census takers ringing my doorbell loudly, banging hard on my door, and leaving demanding notes. Today was the worst, as I had on my air conditioner, which tipped them that someone was home. I’ve also had a lot of calls where they hang up before the message machine kicks in. Months ago, I sent in my household enumeration. But that doesn’t satisfy an abuse government that wants to know everything about us. That smacks of totalitarianism.

Every year more and more people are renouncing their U.S. citizenship, and moving to other countries. It sure sounds tempting.

Carol on August 15, 2010 at 4:56 pm

I know that when person is informed, or seeks out, the correct history of a subject they are much less likely to expouse information they have acquired through a system of beliefs or opinions.
The census is a function created by our constitution for many different reasons. It may have the effect of transfering funds away from corporations and special interests to benefit the public living at the lower end of the ability to influence policy in ones favor. Or it may not.
This is why “knowing”, weather or not to participate in the census should be investigated thouroughly before making a decision.

One dumb thing on August 17, 2010 at 12:13 pm

I was also on the so called Pilot program. Now they keep sending me a so called “Quality Assurance Survey” which asks
very personal and intrusive questions about each member of my family. They first one said it was voluntary and I didn’t have to participate. When I didn’t fill it out they sent another one, telling me to fill it out today. I refuse to bullied by the feds. Sorry I didn’t hit the first choice which was “Hispanic, non-white”. That is no excuse to harrass me. Do they ask the Mexican people if they are “White, non-hispanic” as their first choice, or do the Mexican’s even have a census?

Sheldon on October 11, 2010 at 4:49 pm

Here in Santa Monica, CA they were hiring the ‘homeless’ as census takers to go door to door. Most here on the Promenade are alcoholics In one case the person is severely schizophrenic and on heavy duty medication (I know her mother well).

sgt on December 13, 2010 at 3:26 pm

March of 2011 and we still have a census worker bothering us. I sent the survey in on time. I even answered a follow up survey asking questions like did we count anyone that lives in a nursing home or is away at college. They stopped coming by around November. And last week it started up again. Three slips of paper left, as well as a voicemail. This is absolutely harassment. My husband sent a letter to the regional office asking them to stay off of our property and quite harassing us.

Mary on March 7, 2011 at 6:23 pm

These Census people are ACORN left overs. They are a formerly a prostitution ring and now the work for Census. Sound Censless to me. Anyways its says that the form is a (Sample). Where in the constitution do I have to answer a “randomly selected sample”. As for these loozers in here saying fill out all the info, well its not hard to see people with NOTHING dont mind filling out a 28 page non-sense form, when your a broke ass with no $$$ in the bank. Sure why not fill it out then. Well Im a hard working,savings account having,rental property owner with $$$$ galore in account with Meryl Lynch as well as CD’s in the bank. HOW IS THIS ANY OF THE CENSUS PEOPLE’S INFO. THE IRS HAS THIS INFO AND I GUARNTEE THAT THESE ACORN LOOZERS WILL RUN YOUR HISTORY THRU THE GOV. AGENCY’S TO GET WHAT THEY WANT. I’m contacting FOX News and stirring this shit up.

Census Workers are ACORN PEOPLE on April 27, 2011 at 9:46 am

    I could tell you were “hard working” and “successfull” from the plethora of times you used the word “loser” and its gross misspelling.

    Bleu- on December 31, 2011 at 6:09 pm

I concur with most of the posts on here, I too (was a chosen one) to particiate in this ridiculous American Community Survey. To: (so-called census worker with a brain), you and this whole thing is such a waste of our tax payer’s money.
I sent the form back like most of you,with the number of people living here, just my wife and I. Since that time, I have received a phone call almost every single day for over a month, and lucky me, on my only day off, last Saturday was visited at my house by a very pushy census worker. I refused his questions, then three days later, received an overnight Fedex envelope, sending me the same crap, and threatening me that i would subject to a fine.
I guess this is what our country has stooped to! Harrasing law abiding citizens to become criminals for refusing to give out intrusive personal information.
So today, I sent off a letter to my State Senators, we’ll see what happens!

law abiding citizen on December 13, 2011 at 12:58 pm

These census workers are still bothering me, knocking on the door, windows, etc. My family’s afraid to go out or come in because it’s as if we were being stalked. It’s two years after 2010 already!

As for the law abiding citizen, I find it strange why the government would use fed ex to mail you something. Wouldn’t USPS suffice?

annoyed on January 9, 2012 at 7:04 pm

Leave a Reply

* denotes required field